Nestor Peak


Trip Details
Mountain Range: 
Mountain Subrange: 
Attained Summit?: 
Trip Date: 
Sunday, July 8, 2018
Summit Elevation (m): 
Summit Elevation (ft): 
Elevation Gain (m): 
Round Trip Time: 
Total Distance (km): 
Quick 'n Easy Rating: 
Class 4 : you fall, you are almost dead
Difficulty Notes: 

A very long and tiring day including remote BC bushwhacking, routefinding, exposed ridges and steep snow with possible ice.

Trip Report

On July 8th, 2018, Phil Richards, Eric Coulthard and I spent one of the longer days I've had in the Rockies scrambling and route finding a very likely new route via the north and east ridges of Nestor Peak to its summit. After spending a pretty exhausting 15 hours the day before, approaching the Police Meadows and scrambling both Simpson Ridge and Peak, getting back to the cabin at 22:45, we were quite groggy when my alarm went off at around 04:50 on Sunday morning. There was nothing to do but roll out of my creaky bunk and stumble around in the dim morning light trying to make some coffee and choke down some breakfast. The absolute worst part of the entire day was struggling back into my SOAKING wet approach shoes. That was brutal. Brrrr!


We were all well aware of how difficult and long this day was going to be but we tried to stay positive and focus on the tasks right in front of us rather than the ones further out. Immediate tasks after breakfast were deciding on a route and a strategy for attack. Nestor Peak is not normally a very technical mountain. It's fairly easily ascended from the south - Rick Collier even skied the peak in February, 1991. Due to forest fires and missing bridges, Rick's approach via Surprise Creek and Rock Lake is pretty much no longer feasible, so we were left with our approach over Citadel Pass and Police Meadows to attempt the peak. Only having one day to climb the peak and exit all the way back over Citadel Pass and Sunshine Meadows (a 15-21km, 870m elevation gain on its own) limited our options even further. Option 1 would have us repeating our bushwhack from the previous day up valley from Police Meadows and extending it much further to the head of the valley before ascending either steep snow or the north glacier to the summit. The problem with this option was the horrible bushwhacking and unknown glacier (Google Earth showed some big holes) and the fact that we were in light footwear so cramponing up ice or very steep snow slopes wasn't a very safe option.  The day before, while on Simpson Ridge and Peak, we'd spotted a potential "option 2" route that would not only avoid the horrendous bushwhack, but would offer a spectacular ridge approach to Nestor that was also almost certainly a FKR (first known route). Why an FKR? Because nobody would normally do this route considering how far and complicated it was from the easy south side of the mountain! 


[The lower route options for Nestor Peak seen from Simpson Peak the evening before. The lower route (X) is horrendous bushwhacking. The cabin is circled. We'd ascend the north end of the ridge from Police Meadows and attempt to traverse it all the way to Nestor. ++]

[A view of our approach ridge from the day before on Citadel Pass - smack dab at center here. Nestor in clouds to its right and Simpson Peak at far right.]


As we drank our morning coffees and glanced sideways at the north end of the ridge we decided that this was going to be our option. We could clearly see that this ridge was not only very steep, but it was also very bushy to treeline with cliff bands sprinkled in just for kicks. Eric commented rather dryly that he'd spotted this ridge from our descent of Citadel Pass the day before and remembered thinking, "thank goodness we don't go up there"! We finished packing our day packs and bid the guys in the cabin a good day. They'd be choppering out later and wished us "good luck" before rolling over in their bunks. I sort of wished I was them before pushing the door closed and tramping off after Phil and Eric across the swampy meadows towards the end of the ridge. I have to admit the morning atmosphere in the meadows was very nice. The level of noise coming from the local bird population was almost like a jungle and the soft light from the rising sun on the peaks surrounding us was sublime. Too bad this tranquil mood didn't last long.


[Phil preps his pack as sunlight hits our peak far up valley from the Police Meadows cabin.]

[Yes. This is exactly how our day began!! Why not use the log? It was horribly slick from morning dew and we knew our feet were getting wet in the swamp immediately after the crossing anyway. My feet were going to be soaked for another 18 hours this day... Note Nestor Peak lit up far in the distance above our heads.]


Right from the start our day proved more difficult than most. First of all there was getting 2-4 hours of restless sleep after a 31km, 1900m day before. Than there was the knee deep wade across the creek followed by a shin deep wade across the swamp to exit the meadows before the start of the ridge. And then there was the ridge itself. We knew there'd be bushwhacking and we knew the first hour or two of our day was going to suck, but I think we underestimated a just how much it would suck. We found ourselves once again in thick bush and alders, literally having to pull our tired bodies up steep mossy and rock covered slopes with slick wet dirt underneath it all. To make things even more fun, we kept running into impossibly steep cliff bands which necessitated guessing which way to try finding scramble routes around or through them. In a common theme for the trip, we seemed to make the right guesses very consistently. We encouraged each other more than once that soon enough we'd break treeline and life would be grand again but the trees just kept going and going and going!


[O.M.G. That's all I got for this one.]

[One of many cliffs that we had to routefind around.]

[A glorious mix of moss, mud, cliffs, rocks and of course lots and lots of alders.]

[He's smiling but Eric is NOT having that much fun. Trust me. None of us are at this point.]


Of course, eventually, we were right. We did finally break treeline. It started with a trickle of larch trees and soon we were in a small forest of them. That forest began to thin and we whooped aloud as we took in the views of the surrounding area from the north end of our approach ridge. The whooping was a bit contained, because it was only now that we realized we were in for a much longer day than we originally thought - there was no way we were going to be back at the cabin 8 hours after leaving it. We used our mental boost to propel ourselves upwards - aiming for a high point on the ridge above where I declared I'd, "take a break".


[Finally breaking treeline. Nestor Peak at far left, Simpson Peak and Simpson Ridge to the right of it. The Monarch at center distance up the Simpson River Valley and Citadel Pass area at right. Our approach valley to the Simpsons the day before at mid-left - note the waterfall. ++]


As we crested the high point I immediately saw we likely had an issue. The day before already, while scouting the ridge, Phil and noticed a notch that could prove difficult. I thought the east side of the ridge would be fairly angled but I was proved wrong and Phil was proved right. We did have a problem at the notch - it was not scrambling terrain around it. This is part of what made Nestor Peak such an interesting and memorable day. There was no straightforward or obvious route - we were forced to make many decisions on the "fly" and hope to heck we weren't wasting our day. Any one of half a dozen route choices could have easily ended our attempt at this peak, but each time we made a choice it worked out including this time. As Phil waited a bit nervously behind me on the ridge, I tiptoed out onto the very steep and exposed east face of the ridge, looking for a possible traverse around the notch. I was surprised and delighted to find a possible traverse line and yelled back to the Phil that I was going to keep going. I kept finding and following small scree ledges - terrifically exposed and definitely "no slip zones" - all the way to easier terrain well past the notch! So far so good. Nestor was behaving today.


[Oh oh. A steep wall along the ridge might prove problematic. There's a notch you can't see here that has overhanging rock on the other side of it.]

[This isn't even the exposed part of the traverse yet, but you get the idea. There were very many "no slip" zones and some very delicate steps across exposed gullies that required focus and attention.]

[What a glorious day! Note the green meadow at lower right? The Porcupine / Simpson River trail goes through it.]

[Steeper and more exposed than it appears. There's a reason we didn't want to traverse this on return when we were tired - there were some tricky steps on this face.]


I didn't take a ton of photos of the east face traverse as I was too focused on always finding a way forward. I fully expected to run into impassible terrain but each time I thought our day was done, I'd look up or down and find another little ledge or gully. Before I knew it, I was on easier terrain and back on the ridge crest! Life was very good as we took in the wonderfully clear morning dawning around us in every direction. It was nice to have views for once, after several trips recently with a lot of clouds. We noted that time was passing much too quickly and after waiting for Eric to catch up, we motored on towards the east ridge of Nestor, wondering where the next crux would be.


[Eric finishes up the traverse in this view back down the ridge. Police Meadows at left, Eric at right.]

[Telephoto showing the two cabins at Police Meadows. The trail snaking off to the right leads to the Simpson River Trail.]

[Looking ahead to the rest of the ridge and Nestor Peak with its north pocket glacier.]

[We had some mighty fine positions on the north ridge! Phil is gazing over the Valley of Rocks which is out of sight from my vantage, to the left.]

[The ridge was everything we'd hoped for and more. It was narrow in spots but a terrific scramble above wonderful scenery.]

[Looking back along the ridge at another section we bypassed - this time on our right. Police Meadows catching the morning sun at lower center.]

[One of the hidden tarns lying east of Simpson Peak and north of Nestor.]

[For a while we wondered if this would be our next crux section, but it was remarkably straightforward with great exposure and views. ++]

[Eric follows us along the ridge.]

[Sublime views off the ridge with Nestor at center and Simpson Peak at right with a tarn sparkling beneath. ++]

[A spectacular position on the ridge - note Eric below. In the distance is The Monarch, Mount Ball and peaks around Egypt Lakes.]


Despite some tense moments of wondering what was ahead, the rest of the north ridge went fine. Spectacularly fine, actually! The positions on the ridge crest, the exposure, the cool morning breezes, the views in every direction - it all conspired to really keep the energy levels up and the explor8ion blood running through our veins. Phil and I both felt that our last month of long, remote and rarely traveled ascents had prepared us well for this adventure. Eric was doing his best to keep up to us, but was lagging behind at this point in the day already. He'd had a huge day, the day before already, considering he hadn't been out since December 2017! To be perfectly honest, I was surprised he even got up for Nestor, much less made it this far! I knew that Eric was a tough hombre though and wasn't seeing anything I hadn't seen before from him. As we started the descent to the north / east ridge col, we were delighted to see more sparkling lakes in a hanging valley to the south of us. Mount Assiniboine was busy stealing the show again - as usual for this area. Something interesting happened to my mood as we descended the loose, blocky terrain towards the east ridge - I lost hope.


I'm not sure how it even happened, but suddenly I found myself doubting that the route would go and seeing nothing but impossible obstacles in front of us. It was strange - not something that happens often to me. I even told Phil to "go ahead" because I honestly just didn't feel like dealing with the disappointment of being turned back this far into things. Thankfully the despair only lasted about 30 minutes, after which I realized I was an idiot and the terrain was much easier and much more fun than it appeared from a distance. We scrambled up and over rock ribs and through little terrain holes in the ridge - all while taking in the awesome views of familiar and new peaks in the Assiniboine area.


[Getting closer to the transition from the north ridge to the east ridge of Nestor Peak and wondering if it'll go. Simpson Peak at center with Simpson Ridge to its right. ++]

[Descending to the east ridge from the north one.]

[Find Eric. He's in there somewhere, descending from the north ridge.]

[Phil adds some sense of scale to the terrain on the east ridge of Nestor Peak.]

[Once again we are reminded why the suffering of a new route is worth it. I certainly haven't seen this photo before! Nub peak at left with The Towers, Terrapin, Magog, Assiniboine from L to R in the background.]

[More spectacular scenery on the east ridge looking towards the north glacier and summit above.]

[There were lots of angled little cliffs on the ridge crest, providing hands on, easy scrambling and distracting us from how tired we were and how long this day would be.]

[A flat area on the east ridge with views back towards the core Assiniboine area and an outlier of Nestor.]


Finally we found ourselves nearing the last crux of the day - the notch and glacier just before the summit. Phil raced ahead and peered over the edge of the ridge. He wasn't saying much, so I asked him what was wrong. He very tentatively said that it "might go" directly beneath where he was standing. I caught up to him and peered over the edge. GULP. I mean, yes, it could go, but it looked pretty darn desperate to me! There was very steep, loose downclimbing to a tricky looking transition to the glacier below. I didn't love it. But I knew there was an easy way! I'm not sure how, but I very confidently told Phil to simply keep going to the end of the ridge and there'd be a good route directly into the notch. He was very doubtful - and let me know it - but he kept going. Sure enough! No issues. Easy scrambling down ledges and scree to the col below. YES! I also looked ahead at the glacier / snow slopes to the summit ridge and was pretty confident we'd make it with our axes and crampons. There was very little runout even if we did slip and the terrain looked pretty easy for a short snow climb. We cramponed up at the col and I led up and around a cliff in the ridge before regaining rock off the steep snow. I was very careful to probe the deep moat / crevasse between the snow and the rock, but thankfully found a reasonable spot to cross. The snow was short, fast and fun and now we were looking at easy terrain to the top, which we tackled rather enthusiastically. Nothing feels better than realizing 6 hours into a pretty long day that your unknown, unplanned and on-sight route is going to result in a successful summit!


[Looking at our final crux to the summit - the north pocket glacier over the notch.]

[Phil follows me up the snow / glacier to the summit ridge. It's steep - but very low consequence here.]

[Eric puts on his crampons at the col - note the easy scree bypass on the other side of the notch. Originally Phil thought we had to descend to the glacier on the left side of this photo!]

[Feeling pretty good about life now! Our entire approach ridge at left running to center with Simpson Ridge ending at Nub Peak to the right. Eric is coming up the glacier behind us. ++]

[A great shot of Eric on the north pocket glacier of Nestor with the east ridge stretching out behind him.]


Within minutes we were headed for the summit cairn - placed just under a rather permanent patch of snow at the summit. I instantly noticed a register but was very disappointed to open it and find it thoroughly soaked and pretty much unreadable. frown I could just make out that it was Rick's February ascent in 1991 and there was about 2 pages with 10 other entries after that. Many more entries than I was expecting but this is a pretty easy objective from Ferro Pass with great views of Assiniboine so I guess being one of a dozen or so ascents in a popular area over 27 years isn't so bad. The last entry was written in pen so I could see the "2012" date. We took some time on the summit, eating, hydrating and snapping too many photos. We also started planning our route back to the Police Meadows.


[Our approach ridge at mid-left to mid-center where it joins Simpson Ridge and heads west to the summit of Nestor Peak. Golden Mountain, Nasswald, Cautley, Nub, The Towers, Terrapin, Magog, Assiniboine and The Marshall L to R in the distance. ++]

[Mount Watson at right with Wedgewood Lake beneath.]

[Looking north off the summit towards the rest of Simpson Ridge and towards Banff (C) and Kootenay (L). Kananaskis at distant right. ++]

[Golden Mountain (L) and Nasswald Peak rise across Golden Valley and the Valley of Rocks.]

["Little" and "Big" Fatigue Mountain lie across Citadel Pass.]

[Great views over the partially burned slopes towards the Sunshine Meadows.]

[Gazing down the Simpson River Valley towards Mount Ball (L) with Hector visible at distant center. Simpson Ridge / Mount Edmonton at foreground left.]

[Looking over Citadel Peak towards Lookout Mountain and Mount Howard Douglas.]

[Mount Ball.]

[The burned Verdant Creek Valley with Hawk Ridge lining it at left. The Rockwall visible at left.]

[A panorama of the core Assiniboine area with many familiar Kananaskis peaks in the far distance. ++]

[Our two summits from the previous day visible at left, Simpson Peak in the foreground and Ridge beyond. Police Meadows at mid center right as a patch of light colored green.]

[More nice scenery just beneath the summit. :)]

[Looking over Ferro Pass and the Rock Lake / Upper Surprise Creek valley towards Indian Peak to the west. It's surprising how close the Verdant Creek fire got to the core Assiniboine area - almost cresting Ferro Pass. The Mitchell River drainage between Mount Watson and Indian Peak at mid left - this was the standard approach to Assiniboine for many years but is now mostly only used by outfitters traveling by horseback. ++]

[Rock Lake and the fire damage from the Verdant Creek fire of 2017.]

[The Matterhorn of the Rockies rises over the Mitchell River and Wedgewood Lake to the south of Nestor Peak. The Marshall and Mount Watson to its right are MUCH less often ascended. Mounts Strom and Wedgewood are easy ascents from the Hind Hut and are done quite often - they sit in front of Assiniboine here. ++]


As we discussed our descent route we had two thoughts in mind. Firstly, taking our ascent route would certainly work, but it would take up to 5 or even 6 more hours. Descending the ridge wouldn't be much quicker than the ascent had been, especially on the north end where the cliffs would be problematic. Being tired, we were also cautious about the very exposed "goat traverse" of the east face I'd found on ascent. There were about 4 or 5 "no slip" zones on that traverse and I mean no slip. Not even a slight shuffle  or unplanned sneeze would be good on that exposed dirt / pebble / ledge terrain! Our other options were to take the tempting direct line down into the valley we'd used the day before - heading straight to the Police Meadows and cabin. As tempting as this option was, we knew it would be exhausting and horrible bushwhacking in the very heat of the day and we had another 21km hike with 870m of height gain after getting back to the cabin yet! (We knew we'd miss the Sunshine gondola ride and would have to walk the extra 5.5km road to the parking lot.) With that option off the table there was only one more left. We decided to descend the unknown east side of the north ridge where it becomes "Simpson Ridge" and try to find friendly terrain to the main trail running out of the core area through Golden Valley towards Citadel Pass or the Porcupine Campground / Simpson River.


[Phil is back at the col and preparing to re-ascend the notch on the east ridge.]

[Eric descends the pocket glacier to the bottom of the notch behind us.]

[Views over Sunburst Lake and Lake Magog towards The Towers with Mount Sir Douglas rising beyond.]

[Phil climbs a bump along the east ridge.]

[The small unnamed tarns just south of us were beautiful shades of green / blue. Game Lake is just downstream here and this is the Nestor Creek drainage.]

[Yet another bump on the ridge, but we're getting closer to the north ridge again.]

[Starting our descent down the east side of the ridge into the Valley of Rocks with Golden Mountain at right. Find Phil, relaxing and taking in the scenery - we do sit down for a few minutes when we're forced to!]


Once again, we got very lucky with our chosen route. Snow was a huge asset as we broke through several cliff bands on the NE side of the ridge we'd used for ascent. Several times we couldn't see over steep rolls ahead and were relieved to find snow slopes leading over slabs every time. Eventually we spotted what looked like a clear descent line on mostly open terrain (as indicated on my topo map) that would lead right into the heart of Golden Valley and the main trail. At this point Eric was seriously bagged. We felt sorry for him, as Phil and I were still charging along pretty quickly. We didn't want to lose him, so we had a few long breaks which wasn't a horrible thing of course!


[We had two options here. Left looks nice here but leads to dense bushwhacking lower down and possible cliffs. The notch to the right of Phil here leads down open terrain to the Golden Valley and main trail but could also have slabby cliffs. We chose the right hand notch and it worked perfectly thanks to the snow.]

[The trail is just visible at bottom center. Citadel and Fatigue Passes at mid center.

[Looking down towards our escape ridge at lower right - note the bare rock at the edge of the forest. This ridge trends down to the left and leads directly to the main trail below.]

[Find Eric. We took full advantage of steep snow slopes to avoid slabby cliffs in the terrain behind us here.]

[Looking down the gorgeously green and lush Golden Valley and Simpson River drainage before it's a "river". Our descent ridge sneaks into view at right, trending down and left.]

[Telephoto looking down the Simpson River Valley towards Verdant Creek and showing fire damage. The Monarch and Mount Ball looming over everything else.]


Finally, in the heat of the day, we were back on the main trail running along our ascent ridge to the NE and back towards the turnoff to the Police Meadows. On hindsight I'm not sure we made the best choice of return routes. Sure, our route worked out in the end but it was HOT and LONG and the amount of elevation gains on return were definitely more than we were counting on. I think we focused too much on the fact that we'd be on easy trails, rather than the distance and elevations. Oh well, it worked and we did manage to push our tired bodies along a pretty good clip despite gaining elevation in the heat of the day. We'd agreed with Eric that he'd be staying at the Police Meadows cabin one more night. There was no way he could push his poor body any harder and it was getting a bit risky to try.


Phil and I left Eric at the main trail and started back to the cabin at our own pace - hoping to meet him once more as we came out from the cabin with all our gear on route to a long exit trek. As usual for us, we chatted to pass the time and grumbled every once in a while at the elevation gains, but generally we were pretty darn cheerful considering what was still ahead of us. I had no idea how the heck I was going to push my poor body another 21km and almost 900m of elevation gain! I tried not to think about it as we turned off the trail to Citadel Pass and took the less traveled one toward the Porcupine Campground. Once again we had a lot of elevation changes, but at least the terrain was new. This trail was surprisingly scenic but it was a bit depressing how long it took to finally arrive at the junction to the Police Meadows. I got grumpy again here as we were going all the way back to the cabin only to turn around and hike back out again! The cabin was silent and Greg and his friend had left us a bunch of food and even some fresh, cold Ginger Ale!! I've never tasted pop so refreshing and well timed! It was very nice of them to leave us the food, as Eric didn't have any extra and needed supper and breakfast now that he was staying another night. Talk about good timing!


[On the main trail and going uphill. We vastly underestimated the amount of uphill on this trail.]

[Looking back over a gorgeous waterfall that is one of the sources for the Simpson River.]

[So. Many. Uphill sections!]

[It's hard to believe we ascended this ridge hours and hours earlier as we arrive back in the Police Meadows.]


It was pretty tough to leave the cabin, especially with all the fresh food but after a cup of coffee and the refreshing pop it was time to go. We packed our overnight packs and set off across the meadows one last time, including the "delightful" knee deep stream and swamp crossings! Thankfully we met Eric on our way back down the trail and gave him the good news of fresh food awaiting his arrival. He perked up noticeably at that. As we made our way through the Porcupine Campground, a gentleman asked us where we'd come from and where we were going. We pointed disinterestedly behind us, "from there" and in front of us, "to there". cheeky He grinned back, "I understand" and we kept marching on. The climb back up the steep trail to Citadel Pass went better than either of us thought it would. We simply slowed things down and focused on one foot in front of the other. Slowly we crept along and eventually we were looking back and realizing how high we were again.


[A last look back at the cabin as we exit the Police Meadows. Nestor at distant center here.]

[Leaving the meadows as the shadows already start to lengthen.]

[Back across the Simpson River - more of a bubbling brook at this point.]

[Many hundreds of meters up Citadel Pass, looking back at our ascent ridge on Nestor with the peak at right distance. Man have we gained a LOT of height today already!]


The rest of our exit was a bit of a blur - each of us lost increasingly in our own thoughts as our bodies slowly went numb from exhaustion and exercise. The grunt up and over the Quartz Hill shoulder was pretty tiring but nothing compared to the unending sufferfest that was the Sunshine road to the parking lot! We were walking zombies at this point and walked into the parking lot right at midnight. My "Move Ring" on the iWatch spun around 5 times - a new record for me! Apparently I burned around 7,500 calories and did over 66,000 steps in this 18 hour marathon. That explains the slight stiffness in my left knee the next day anyway... wink


[Grunting up the Quartz Hill shoulder from the Howard Douglas Lake Campground as the sun sets.]

[A great view back from the shoulder, looking past Citadel Peak at the left towards Assiniboine and Nestor Peak at right. ++]

[The sun sets but we have many hours to go yet.]


Overall, Nestor Peak and the entire weekend was a great experience in the Rockies for me. We pioneered at least one and probably two new routes to three peaks with stunning views in all directions. We hiked over 75km and 4400m of elevation gain in 2 marathon days, pushing ourselves mentally and physically in every way with bushwhacking and route finding. Sure - it was exhausting too. We certainly can't do these types of trips every weekend without doing permanent damage to ourselves. But doing it this once proved that we are capable of even more and once again we got to realize our potential for suffering while also greatly enjoying the incredible backcountry of the Rockies.


What an epic! Impressive suffering from some unique, amazing views!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Enter the characters shown in the image.